Get the best of cottage style directly in your inbox!
C&B Project House
Bathroom Reveal! Balancing Old & New
While the bathrooms in the farmhouse are new additions, the Bridgers share how they made the spaces feel fresh.

We’ve been following Christine and Gabe Bridger and their family in their renovation of a 1910 Michigan farmhouse. After poring over images and floor plans, and taking walks around the property with Jon Faris of Paradigm Renovation—parts of the process you can catch up on at cottagesandbungalows.com—the Bridgers tackled the home’s bathrooms.

And it’s time for us to bring you the nitty gritty of that adventure.

The chic black-and-white cement tile, shapely claw-foot tub, shiplap with cedar planks and a hand towel Christine picked up in Greece create a classic color palette with a modern flair.
The upstairs bathroom is a new addition to the home’s footprint. Shiplap walls help add age and integrate it into the rest of the home.

Black Beauty

While Christine and Gabe strive for period appropriateness, when it came to the bathrooms, they wanted to use the opportunity to add some contrast. “What we wanted to do,” Christine says, “is have the bathrooms be the opposite of the rest of the home.” Whereas the rest of the home is predominantly white (a period authentic choice) with touches of black and red, the bathrooms flip the emphasis, with a black base punctuated by accents of white and restrained pops of red.

The downstairs bathroom is small at just 5×7 feet, but built-in storage with glass-fronted doors allows for a stylish way to house supplies. The Gridscape shower door from Coastal Shower Doors recalls the look of an old warehouse window and imparts the renovated space with just the kind of vintage vibe Christine was looking for.
White subway tile with white grout provides gives the downstairs bathroom a period look. The black accents are crowned by a black tile border above that mimics the effect of crown molding in a modern industrial way.

The downstairs bathroom is fairly small (about 5 x 7 feet), but the ceilings are 9 feet high. Black hexagonal tiles on the floor lead into pencil strips of black subway tile on the walls. Upstairs, a claw-foot vintage-style Kohler tub is black on the outside and white on the inside. While this inverted color scheme and what Christine calls a “nod from simplistic, minimal industrial” style make the bathroom a bit different from the rest of the home,

Christine and Gabe are still careful to keep the overall feel cohesive. They incorporated wood from an original floor joist into the weathered shelf in the upstairs bathroom.

Upstairs, the bathroom is part of the addition, but they continued the feel of the original home by installing shiplap with cedar plank tongue-and-groove boards from Lowes. They also commissioned a custom-made screen to look like a salvaged shop window, which will tie in with a salvaged picture window in the kitchen. Christine also customized caddies to look old by blasting them with a hand sander.

The tall 9-foot ceilings in the downstairs bathroom provided a great opportunity to use these eye-catching black framed shower doors. It was a great way to add signature style to a small space.

Spatial Challenges

Historic homes are reflections of their era, which is of course part of their charm, but floor-plan issues can also quickly arise. In the early 1900s, when the farmhouse was built, bathrooms were viewed as only functional spaces and consequently ran small. While the Bridgers could not salvage the original bathroom, the downstairs bathroom is the same size as the original at 5 x 7 feet.

The original bathroom had suffered a bad remodel in the 1980s, which removed everything but a door. The Bridgers were able to use that door for a linen closet adjoining the bathroom. Working within the period-appropriate space was “a jigsaw puzzle,” Christine says. In fact, originally she intended the claw-foot tub for the downstairs bathroom, not taking into account its slanted edge. Once the tub arrived, it overwhelmed the space. Fortunately they could use it in the upstairs bathroom.

Upstairs there are three bedrooms and only one bathroom. Since the whole family would be using the upstairs bathroom for brushing their teeth at night, “We wanted it to be as communal as possible,” Christine says. A large utility sink serves just that purpose. To compensate for the lack of counter space, they were able to use a weathered piece of wood from the original home and had it custom made into a shelf mounted on 3-inch iron brackets. Kitchen barstools on either side provide additional surface area to use in lieu of a counter.

The three-faucet Kohler sink is a functional and stylistically appropriate choice in this shared bathroom. Kitchen stools and a piece of the original floor that was custom-made into a shelf provide surface area in lier of a counter. The customized mirror and exterior-style light add an extra farmhouse decorative touch.

Vintage & Modern

In a functional space like a bathroom, it can be hard to find salvage items up to the task of daily use for something like a tub. When you shop secondhand, “sometimes you run out of time because the nature of it is so one-off,” Christine says. Or, she relates, sometimes the cost of getting a salvaged find like a vintage tub is more than if you bought new. New, however, can still maintain a vintage feel. Kohler’s heritage line claw-foot tub, for instance, feels appropriate to the home’s era and the overall authenticity of the home.

“Even with new items,” Christine says, “we wanted to make sure they felt like they could have been in the home from the beginning.” Christine and Gabe’s sense of what suits the home’s era comes from their research visiting historic homes and pubs in their area. In the downstairs bathroom, for instance, Christine describes that the black sink cabinet has “a modern feel but still with old charm,” like the spindled legs.

When it comes to lighting, Christine has layered in fixtures reminiscent of the period, but the technology is very much modern. Christine chose Philips Vintage LED A19 light bulbs, which look vintage but can be controlled from a smartphone. Since the lights are open and you can see the bulbs prominently, Christine says, “it was important to have a vintage feel.”

“Pendleton towels are my signature,” Christine says. They are both durable and beautiful and are an easy way to pack a big style punch with a small accent.
The old farmhouse is not without a few new modern luxuries such as this ceiling-mount speaker from Sonos.

Christine’s Hard-Won Advice

Learn from the Bridgers’ experience before you dive into your own bathroom project.

  • Measure twice; order once. You find this out the hard way sometimes. But especially if you are taking on DIY projects in a small space, “precise measurement is key,” Christine says.
  • Buy inexpensive basics and customize to make them feel period appropriate with some DIY touches. For example, the Bridgers used a $50 mirror from Lowes and added a wooden frame to it themselves for another $100—still dramatically less expensive than buying a framed mirror of that size new.
  • Think through your claw-foot tub. These tubs look gorgeous on the page, but Christine cautions, “Be careful.” “Claw foot tubs are beautiful,” she says, “but they are not as simple to install or even to use. We sacrificed some function for design” with the tub/shower combo in the upstairs bathroom. In addition to concerns of space, think about where you will mount the tub itself, as well as the faucet and whether the plumbing will come from the floor or the wall. Another thing to keep in mind is that if you want to make it a functional shower as well, that involves separate plumbing, a showerhead, and requires a curtain rod and curtain around the whole tub. The Bridgers loved the “rain/spa-like element” of their Kohler Moxie showerhead, which involved separate plumbing through the ceiling.
  • Layer patterns with a black-and-white base. When you start with a black-and-white base and even a black-and-white pattern, you can “layer in colored patterns without it looking weird.” One of Christine’s favorite ways to layer in pattern is with Pendleton towels. “It’s my signature,” she says, and while they cost more, “they last forever” and can also be used as beach towels. Christine will collect them over time, so that eventually she will have an eclectic, colorful collection that serves both functional and decorative purposes.
  • Don’t use flat paint in a bathroom. Christine warns that this is a popular choice for painters and builders since it’s cheaper, but “when you go to clean it, it almost comes off,” Christine says. The Bridgers prefer eggshell or satin paints for their look and better durability.

Watch Cottage Renovation Video: 5 Tips for any Bathroom Remodel